HOME / HUNTERDON COUNTY / FLEMINGTON, NJ

31 CHURCH ST, FLEMINGTON, NJ

31 CHURCH ST is Block 41, Lot 26 in Flemington, NJ. See all properties on Church St.

$259,000

Total assessed value

$8,116

Annual property tax (2025)

~$237,482

Est. market value

Estimated market value: ~$237,482. This home is assessed at $259,000, and homes in Flemington are assessed at about 109% of market value on average (NJ Division of Taxation, 2025) — so the estimated market value is roughly ~$237,482. Assessments here run above market value on average — a town-wide appeal signal.

What's this home worth today?

Our estimate above (~$237,482) uses Flemington's average assessment-to-market ratio. For a home-specific estimate that factors in 31 Church St's condition, upgrades, and recent nearby sales, get a free current market valuation.

31 CHURCH ST is a Residential (4 Families or less) property with 1733 sq/ft of space. Taxes are $8,116 annually. This property was built in 1910 and is owned by MAHN, EDWARD B & JANICE I who lives at 12 BROAD VIEW PLACE. This property was last sold on 1982-12-16 for $0. This property is valued at $149 per sq/ft based on total assessment. This property is zoned DBII, The building description is 2S-F and land description is .22.

Block	Lot	Qual
41	26
Owner	Owner Address	Owner City/State/Zip
MAHN, EDWARD B & JANICE I	12 BROAD VIEW PLACE	FLEMINGTON NJ 08822
Property Class	Square Ft	Year Built
2 - Residential (4 Families or less)	1733	1910

Last Sold
31 CHURCH ST, FLEMINGTON, NJ

Year Sold	Sales Price
1982-12-16	$0

Assessments
31 CHURCH ST, FLEMINGTON, NJ

Total assessed value by year Land Building

Year	Owner	Land Assessment	Building Assessment	Total Assessment	Exemption	Assessed
2021	MAHN, EDWARD B & JANICE I	$105,000	$154,000	$259,000	$0	$259,000
2020	MAHN, EDWARD B & JANICE I	$105,000	$150,400	$255,400	$0	$255,400
2019	MAHN, EDWARD B & JANICE I	$103,900	$149,200	$253,100	$0	$253,100
2018	MAHN, EDWARD B & JANICE I	$102,900	$148,000	$250,900	$0	$250,900
2017	MAHN, EDWARD B & JANICE I	$102,900	$143,100	$246,000	$0	$246,000
2016	MAHN, EDWARD B & JANICE I	$102,900	$141,900	$244,800	$0	$244,800
2015	MAHN, EDWARD B & JANICE I	$102,900	$138,200	$241,100	$0	$241,100
2014	MAHN, EDWARD B & JANICE I	$102,900	$134,500	$237,400	$0	$237,400
2013	MAHN, EDWARD B & JANICE I	$102,900	$129,600	$232,500	$0	$232,500
2012	MAHN, EDWARD B & JANICE I	$114,300	$136,200	$250,500	$0	$250,500
2011	MAHN, EDWARD B & JANICE I	$119,000	$138,700	$257,700	$0	$257,700
2010	MAHN, EDWARD B & JANICE I	$119,000	$145,000	$264,000	$0	$264,000
2009	MAHN, EDWARD B & JANICE I	$132,300	$170,200	$302,500	$0	$302,500

Properties Near
31 CHURCH ST, FLEMINGTON, NJ

Street Address	Owner	Block	Lot	Class
18 CHURCH ST	TURNTABLE & FULPER LLC C/O J GOLD	37	6	4A
19 CHURCH ST	PFS FINANCIAL 1 LLC	35	65	2
20 CHURCH ST	KLIM PROPERTIES LLC	37	4	4A
21 CHURCH ST	MENENDEZ, ANGEL E & MARIA S	41	1	2
22 CHURCH ST	NAVOA, RAMON	37	5	2
23 CHURCH ST	TAYL-MAX PROPERTIES LLC	41	30	4A
24 CHURCH ST	SIEBERT, DOUGLAS P & ANDREA KENNEDY	37	6.01	2
25 CHURCH ST	ABBOTT, HENRY T & JESSICA G	41	29	2
27 CHURCH ST	TAY-MAX PROPERTIES LLC	41	28	2
29 CHURCH ST	PANKO, MICHAEL & BLANCHE	41	27	2
30 CHURCH ST	MAZZETTA, GERALD & KAY	37	8	4A
39 CHURCH ST	VLIET, VIVIAN & MATTHEW KEINATH	42	41	2
41 CHURCH ST	O'DONNELL, BONNIE N & ROBERT	42	40	4A
45 CHURCH ST	HART, ANDREW	42	39	2

The property-related information for 31 CHURCH ST, FLEMINGTON, NJ displayed on this page is obtained from public records from FLEMINGTON, NJ and other sources. While such information is thought to be reliable, it is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. njtaxrecords.net makes no warranties or representations whatsoever regarding the quality, content, completeness, accuracy or adequacy of such information and data. We last updated our database for 31 CHURCH ST, FLEMINGTON, NJ from public sources on 2022-04-02 06:15:44 UTC.

31 CHURCH ST, FLEMINGTON, NJ