NJ Tax Records Search Tax Rates Appeal Guide Legal Redact My Information
HOME / MONMOUTH COUNTY / MIDDLETOWN, NJ

49 PAPE DR, MIDDLETOWN, NJ

49 PAPE DR, MIDDLETOWN, NJ

49 PAPE DR is Block 746, Lot 71 in Middletown, NJ. See all properties on Pape Dr.
Aerial view of 49 Pape Dr, Middletown, NJ
Aerial view of 49 Pape Dr. Imagery: NJ Office of GIS (2020), public domain.
$613,300
Total assessed value
$9,692
Annual property tax (2025)
~$570,627
Est. market value
Estimated market value: ~$570,627. This home is assessed at $613,300, and homes in Middletown are assessed at about 107% of market value on average (NJ Division of Taxation, 2025) — so the estimated market value is roughly ~$570,627. Assessments here run above market value on average — a town-wide appeal signal.
This home is assessed at $369/ft² (1660 sq ft) — in line with the typical Middletown home at $376/ft².

What's this home worth today?

Our estimate above (~$570,627) uses Middletown's average assessment-to-market ratio. For a home-specific estimate that factors in 49 Pape Dr's condition, upgrades, and recent nearby sales, get a free current market valuation.

49 PAPE DR is a Residential (4 Families or less) property with 1660 sq/ft of space. Taxes are $9,692 annually. This property was built in 1988 and is owned by BEHRING, LAUREN who lives at 49 PAPE DRIVE. This property was last sold on 2021-08-04 for $450,000. This property is valued at $271 per sq/ft based on sales price. This property is valued at $369 per sq/ft based on total assessment. This property is zoned RTH1, The building description is BLDG.3 TYPE C and land description is 1.41 %.

Block Lot Qual
746 71  
Owner Owner Address Owner City/State/Zip
BEHRING, LAUREN 49 PAPE DRIVE ATLANTIC HIGHLANDS, NJ 07716
Property Class Square Ft Year Built
2 - Residential (4 Families or less) 1660 1988

Last Sold
49 PAPE DR, MIDDLETOWN, NJ

Year Sold Sales Price
2021-08-04 $450,000

Assessments
49 PAPE DR, MIDDLETOWN, NJ

13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
Total assessed value by year Land Building
Year Owner Land Assessment Building Assessment Total Assessment Exemption Assessed
2026 BEHRING, LAUREN $305,000 $308,300 $613,300 $0 $613,300
2025 BEHRING, LAUREN $295,000 $305,500 $600,500 $0 $600,500
2024 BEHRING, LAUREN $261,000 $303,500 $564,500 $0 $564,500
2023 BEHRING, LAUREN $191,100 $286,100 $477,200 $0 $477,200
2022 BEHRING, LAUREN $170,000 $270,100 $440,100 $0 $440,100
2021 NOTARNICOLA, PAUL R $165,000 $212,800 $377,800 $0 $377,800
2020 NOTARNICOLA, PAUL R $165,000 $208,000 $373,000 $0 $373,000
2019 NOTARNICOLA, PAUL R $165,000 $209,500 $374,500 $0 $374,500
2018 NOTARNICOLA, PAUL R $155,000 $199,800 $354,800 $0 $354,800
2017 NOTARNICOLA, PAUL R $150,000 $196,200 $346,200 $0 $346,200
2016 NOTARNICOLA, PAUL R $170,000 $174,100 $344,100 $0 $344,100
2015 NOTARNICOLA, PAUL R $170,000 $167,400 $337,400 $0 $337,400
2014 NOTARNICOLA, PAUL R $120,000 $165,500 $285,500 $0 $285,500
2013 NOTARNICOLA, PAUL R $120,000 $165,500 $285,500 $0 $285,500

Properties Near
49 PAPE DR, MIDDLETOWN, NJ

Street Address Owner Block Lot Qual Class
35 PAPE DR DUNN, MARYELLEN 746 78   2
37 PAPE DR SIMINSKY, LAURA 746 77   2
39 PAPE DR OCONNOR, CHRISTOPHER 746 76   2
41 PAPE DR O'CONNOR, KEITH F & DENISE R 746 75   2
43 PAPE DR DELAURO, ANTHONY F. & DONNA K. 746 74   2
45 PAPE DR KELLY, SHARON 746 73   2
47 PAPE DR DUNN, PATRICIA E. 746 72   2
51 PAPE DR WEIGAND, GAYLE 746 70   2
52 PAPE DR HERR, PAUL 746 85   2
53 PAPE DR FOULKS, SHIRLEY MONTGOMERY & GARY P 746 69   2
54 PAPE DR ENG, KAI Y & HUANG, GUIHONG 746 86   2
55 PAPE DR MONTANI, ROBERT & ROSEMARIE 746 68   2
56 PAPE DR PACHECO, CASIMIRO J & ANAPAULA G 746 87   2
57 PAPE DR HIRSCHFELD, SCOTT & ANDERSON, RANDY 746 67   2
58 PAPE DR DAVIS, ROBERT & NOONAN,MAUREEN 746 88   2
59 PAPE DR DEMPSTER, PATRIC & GEORGIA 746 66   2
60 PAPE DR THOMPSON, TODD E & STEVENS V.V. 746 89   2
61 PAPE DR HOFFMANN, JENNIFER 746 65   2
62 PAPE DR HEATH, WILLIAM M & JO ANN 746 90   2
63 PAPE DR MIKAITIS, SUSAN 746 64   2

The property-related information for 49 PAPE DR, MIDDLETOWN, NJ displayed on this page is obtained from public records from MIDDLETOWN, NJ and other sources. While such information is thought to be reliable, it is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. njtaxrecords.net makes no warranties or representations whatsoever regarding the quality, content, completeness, accuracy or adequacy of such information and data. We last updated our database for 49 PAPE DR, MIDDLETOWN, NJ from public sources on 2026-06-17 06:18:49 UTC.